EP 33 | We Need to Talk About the Term "AI Therapist"

"Therapy, at its core, is about relationship. And relationship is the one thing AI cannot replicate." I've been sitting with a Facebook post I came across this week — one of dozens I've seen in therapist groups about AI therapists — and I can't stop thinking about the words we're using. Not just what we're debating, but the language we're reaching for to describe it. In this solo episode, I'm deconstructing the phrase "AI therapist" and asking whether we — as a field — are doing ourselves harm just by using it.

In this episode, I'm sharing:

• Why the words we use to describe AI in therapy aren't neutral — and why merging "AI" with "therapist" is doing real damage to how we understand both
• What AI actually is right now: an LLM drawing on curated, publicly available information that reflects the biases of dominant culture — not a thinking being, not a relationship
• What therapy actually is at its core — and why I still can't define it in one paragraph after 20 years
• The diversity of therapeutic relationships that makes the art of therapy so irreplaceable: the therapist who connects with nonverbal children with autism, the one who builds trust with trauma survivors, the one who earns credibility with skeptical high-achieving executives
• Why AI can reproduce the structure of CBT, DBT, IFS, and narrative therapy — and why that is fundamentally not the same as practising any of them
• The data question: why would billionaires who built these platforms actually want access to the deepest, darkest secrets of millions of people?
• What my dad — a Chilean refugee who came to Canada after the assassination of a president — said about things that are offered for free
• Why arguing with each other about AI in therapist Facebook groups is not the same as having the discourse we actually need
• A call to reclaim the word "therapist" as human-centric — and to stop providing language that normalizes the merger

This episode is a question, not an answer. If it sparked something for you, I want to have a real conversation about it. Come find me on LinkedIn — link in the show notes — and weigh in. This discourse needs more voices, not fewer. 👉 ceciliamannella.com

ABOUT YOUR HOST: Cecilia Mannella is a Registered Social Worker, Clinical Counsellor, and therapy practice coach with 25 years as a mental health practitioner and nearly two decades building her own practice from solo therapist to seven-figure group practice. She helps Canadian therapists build profitable, sustainable businesses without apologising for their ambition — or compromising their values.

Connect with Cecilia:

Website: https://www.ceciliamannella.com/

This Episode: https://www.ceciliamannella.com/purpose-and-profit-podcast

LOVED THIS EPISODE?

⭐ Share this with a therapist who's been using the phrase "AI therapist" without thinking twice about it

⭐ Leave a review if this episode gave you language for something you've been uneasy about

⭐ Send this to a colleague who's been arguing about AI instead of having the harder conversation

⭐ Hit follow for more honest conversations about what it actually takes to lead a therapy practice

PURPOSE AND PROFIT: THE SUSTAINABLE THERAPY PRACTICE PODCAST Burnout Is Not a Business Model New episodes every Tuesday © CM Consulting — All Rights Reserved

Work with me: Apply for Coaching

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScnLHz7NPQMjMruYHZij6SJbSBI8JibryK-dGxHcDFhM9VZ9A/viewform